IB課程允許學生使用ChatGPT寫論文 港大則宣布禁止
AI聊天機械人ChatGPT近期在學術界引起爭議，有學府禁止使用，擔心助長作弊行為。但有些學校認為程式可被適當使用。據英國《泰晤士報》報道，香港學生修讀的IB課程容許學生使用ChatGPT，只要標明來源及不涉及剽竊。
IB課程的評估與實務主任Matt Glanville接受訪問時表示，將人工智能生成的作品當成自己的作品違反學術誠信，但這不等於要禁止使用它，學校應幫助學生以合乎道德的方式使用AI。他認為，長遠來看，人工智能可節省學校教授論文寫作的時間，這些時間可用於理解和分析疑難，教育界應該慶祝而非恐懼。
然而，香港大學最近公佈政策，禁止在任何學分制活動中使用ChatGPT及其他AI工具，違規者將被視為「潛在抄襲」。香港大學的副校長（教學）何立仁表示，學校正考慮AI工具對教學的影響，將邀請師生參與討論。
總的來說，ChatGPT在學術寫作中的使用引起爭議，學校和大學需要在教育中使用AI的益處和風險之間取得平衡。
International Baccalaureate Allows Students to Use ChatGPT to Write Essays
The use of the AI chatbot ChatGPT has been controversial in academic circles, with some universities around the world banning its use due to concerns of facilitating cheating. However, some schools believe that the program can be used appropriately. According to the UK’s Times newspaper, the International Baccalaureate (IB) program, which is popular among Hong Kong students, will not prohibit students from using ChatGPT as long as they cite the source and do not engage in plagiarism.
Matt Glanville, the assessment and practice manager for the IB program, stated in an interview with The Times that while presenting AI-generated work as one’s own is a violation of academic integrity, it does not mean that its use should be banned. Schools should assist students in using AI in ethical ways. He believes that AI could ultimately save schools time in teaching essay writing, which could be used to help students understand and analyze difficult topics.
In contrast, the University of Hong Kong has recently announced a policy banning the use of ChatGPT and other AI tools in any credit-bearing activities. Violators will be considered to have potentially plagiarized the work of others. The university’s deputy provost for teaching, Dr. Kelvin Ho, stated that the university is considering the impact of such tools on teaching and will invite faculty and students to discuss their use in the future.
Overall, while the use of ChatGPT in academic writing may be controversial, it is clear that there are differing opinions on the matter. It is important for schools and universities to find a way to balance the benefits and risks of using AI in education.
